Saturday, September 24, 2022
Help Support Local Journalism

Steeped in Scandal, Ukiah Police Face Lawsuit Accusing Officers of Beating Another Defenseless Man

Arturo Valdes, his left eye swollen and his nose broken in a booking photo taken at the Mendocino County Sheriff’s Office

The Ukiah Police Department is going to federal court again, with officers accused of brutalizing another unarmed man. The latest allegation involves a beating that took place at a private residence just a few days before officers beat Gerardo Magdaleno, a naked, mentally ill man in a South Ukiah parking lot. The City settled that case for $211,000, plus attorneys’ fees of approximately $92,500, according to Izaak Schwaiger, Magdaleno’s attorney.

The Valdes complaint, filed in the Northern California US District Court two months ago, claims that on March 28 of last year, Officer Eric Rodello held Arturo Valdes while Sergeant Ronald Donahue punched him in the face, causing multiple injuries that continue to interfere with his ability to breathe through his nose. Rodello and Donohue were not among the four officers caught on camera beating Magdaleno.

According to the Ukiah Police email directory, there are currently 28 members of the Ukiah Police force (counting two community services officers and a property officer, but not counting the dispatch and records manager and the dispatch supervisor.) Two officers and a sergeant are listed in the Valdes complaint. Three officers, a lieutenant, and former Chief Justin Wyatt were named in the Magdaleno beating. (Wyatt was not present at the beating, but was faulted for lack of leadership and training.) Former Chief Noble Waidelich is being investigated for an allegation of assault and is facing a domestic violence trial. Former Sergeant Kevin Murray, who recently pled no contest to felony intimidation and misdemeanor false imprisonment, is facing criminal sentencing in August and a civil complaint by former UPD Officer Isabel Siderakis. In all, ten members of the Ukiah Police force have been implicated in violence in the past year and a half.

The fourteen-count complaint also lists Valdes’ wife Elizabeth and the couple’s two small children as plaintiffs, saying Rodello and Donahue and a third officer, Daniel Parker, handcuffed Elizabeth Valdes and placed her in the back of a police car with the windows rolled up. According to the complaint, officers told her she would lose custody of her children if she declined to provide them with information about a ‘fender bender’ that took place earlier that day in the parking lot of the Ross department store.

Richard Middlebrook, a Bakersfield attorney who is representing the Valdes family, says there was no injury or property damage in the minor collision, and that Valdes gave the other party his driver’s license and insurance information. According to Middlebrook, the other person refused to return the license, and Valdes went home. Police officers retrieved the license from the other person, and came to the Valdes residence a little after 7 pm.

In Middlebrook’s account, the officers asked Arturo Valdes if he had been involved in a hit and run, which Valdes denied. “There was no hit and run, because in order to have a hit and run, you have to have damage which you refuse to take responsibility for or leave information about,” Middlebrook argued. He said the officers told Valdes that they could smell alcohol, and that Valdes was on probation for a prior DUI. The complaint states that at the time of the arrest, Valdes was no longer on probation. Middlebrook said officers told him he was required to take a breath test, and Valdes did not argue.

But now, Arturo Valdes is being prosecuted by the Mendocino County District Attorney’s office 

for driving under the influence, child endangerment, and resisting arrest. Middlebrook says it’s impossible to prove whether or not Valdes was under the influence at the time of the collision (when police believe the children were in the car), because officers met him at his home some time afterwards. And he’s skeptical about claims that Valdes was resisting arrest, because he says his client wasn’t being arrested when the beating took place.

“They said, ‘you’re not under arrest,’ multiple times,” Middlebrook reported. “And then said, you’re not entitled to speak to a lawyer, since you’re not under arrest. That is a flagrant lie, and a misstatement of almost every bit of case law ever, involving the right to speak to an attorney.”   

Describing the video (which we have not viewed), Middlebrook said Donahue began to walk to the front door of the residence, while Arturo Valdes walked toward the garage. He said then, the officers grabbed Valdes by the arms. “When the officer comes up and grabs him from behind, my client turns around and pulls his arm away and says, ‘What are you doing? Am I under arrest? Am I being detained?’ He said, ‘You’re being detained.’ And he said, ‘Why am I being detained?’ And they grab him, throw him face-first into his own car, then throw him to the ground, hold him down, and beat him.”

Middlebrook says the officers falsified the arrest report, which is easily proven by the fact that their statements are contradicted by Ring cameras at the Valdes residence. “One of my concerns in this case from the beginning,” he said, “is that these officers will testify according to what they wrote in their police report, when we know that their police report is fraudulent.” This, he said, could cause legal problems in court, “if they answered questions that incriminated them criminally, that they could be prosecuted for those answers.” 

He said the officers found a way around that, at a recent preliminary hearing, when he asked Donahue, “‘How many times did you strike my client in my face in order to break five bones in his face?’ At that time, he said, ‘I’m going to take the Fifth Amendment against self-incrimination, and I refuse to answer the question.’” According to Middlebrook, Rodello likewise stated that he planned to plead the Fifth, which “throws a huge monkey wrench into this whole criminal case,” because if the officers don’t testify under cross-examination, prior testimony is likely to be thrown out. “If you can’t or will not answer questions under cross-examination in the case, and the entire testimony is then removed, there is no evidence against my client whatsoever, and the case will be dismissed,” he predicted.

Valdes-complaint

Deputy District Attorney Heidi Larson did not return an email asking questions about the case, specifically the implications of Middlebrook’s account of the sergeant’s testimony. 

There will be another hearing in The People vs Valdes on August 19th. Deputy Ukiah City Manager Shannon Riley said she was in meetings all day yesterday and was not able to provide information about the case in time to meet our deadline.

The civil suit that the Valdes family is bringing against the city of Ukiah, the police department and the three policemen is just getting started. Charges against the city include willful negligence that allows for multiple instances of expensive police misconduct.

“It’s rampant,” Middlebrook said. “It’s overwhelming. Almost one-third of the officers have had civil rights violations lawsuits filed against them in the last year and a half alone. I’ve never heard of anything like that in any other department…not only when there’s smoke there’s fire. This is when there’s fire there’s fire. You see the whole police department burning down. At some point, it’s systemic. It goes from the top down.”


Our Coverage of the Scandals Surrounding the Ukiah Police Department


Our Coverage of Kevin Murray

The Gerardo Magdaleno Beating

The Termination of Chief Noble Waidelich

ClarkesTreeServiceVersion2
ClarkesTreeServiceVersion2
ClarkesTreeServiceVersion2
ClarkesTreeServiceVersion2

7 COMMENTS

  1. I believe there would be hundreds if not thousands of VALID misconducts complaints against law enforcement in Mendocino County if only someone outside or above Mendocino County would ask. I told my complaint to the DA office and they, the judge, and the public defenders office ALL covered up the officers misconduct. And because of it a person was charged with two felonies based on a fictitious police report made by the “officer”. There was proof on the officers body cam but it mysteriously wouldn’t download. And therefore it was never produced and now a young man’s life has been ruined because of it. Incidentally, this officer has not yet been in the limelight but I’m expecting him there at some point.

    Mendo Fever, you haven’t even begun to scratch the surface of the offenses committed by ALL branches of Law Enforcement in Mendocino County.

    I know of three cases besides my loved one. I watched LEO pull up in pickup truck belonging to task force and walk out of his apartment with a Walmart bag full of what my neighbor said was cash, etc. One officer was in uniform. They beat him up as well at a different location and apparently took his house keys while he was detained because they went to his house without him. I watched them go in and come out ,together, and walk to the unmarked truck parked across the street with the Walmart bag. Yes, I had a conversation with my neighbor about it.

    In another incident, a woman who worked for me was beat up by some officers. And has spoken with a lawyer about it. It was more than a couple years back. They’ve been doing this for a long time and they’re victims are often drunk, drug addicted, or disabled.

    Another person was pulled over by a marked vehicle and relieved of his “contents” or in plain English he was “robbed” of a large amount of medication he was transporting. Transported to jail for the night but not charged. We have criminals running this poop show taking bribes from the cartel. Just like in Mexico.

    This is America. Expose them!

    Trust me when I say if you’re being approached by law enforcement officers in or out of uniform, please make sure you stop in a well lit area with as many witnesses as possible. Because there will be cameras on cell phones rolling.

    DO NOT stop your vehicle in a dimly lit area. You will not be safe. The corruption doesn’t stop with uniformed officers, it’s rampant here. From the DA’s office, Public Defenders office, Judges, they’re all in bed together with each other and the Sheriffs office, and the City police. Some of them are obviously doped up. You can tell by looking at them.

  2. Wow- more than a third of the Department has been investigated for some sort of misconduct recently! Maybe its time as a community to talk more about police reform? Or is violence acceptable to us when done by the State?

    If nothing else it’s going to cost us taxpayers A LOT of money….id rather my taxes go to the local schools than to pay off the misdeeds of local cops.

  3. I say get rid of the leadership and replace them with someone who will definately. NOT tolerate a crooked department. You’re only as good as your leadership.

    Wasn’t there a Florida police department not too long ago that got scrapped completely and started over with an entirely new staff? I wonder how they’re doing now? Maybe that’s what we need here.

  4. These people are paid by our taxes & entrusted to protect & serve our community but instead violate our constitutional rights regularly. The judges & DA get judical immunity & cops get paid leave, aka paid vacation, or a slap on the wrist for wrong doing?! They’re allowed to operate how they see fit without accountability or oversight. This has given them a God complex. They need to be stripped of jobs & pension if they are guilty of corruption & rights violations. I know they have a very difficult & thankless job but they chose they’re career paths. Honor your oaths!

  5. Ukiah police department is really bad . Quit beating up these harmless guys that need help . Help them instead of hurting them . They need to be fired , n quit being raciest .

  6. Dirty cops are the worst criminals. There is a place for them in the general population in a Federal supermax! Violating the rights they swore an oath to protect. LOCK”EM UP

Leave a Reply to Elizabeth Cancel reply

Sarah Reith
Sarah Reith
Sarah Reith is a radio and print reporter working in Mendocino and Humboldt counties, focusing on local politics and environmental news.

Today's News

How Can I Support MendoFever?

News from the Week

%d bloggers like this: